Why did Loons not go after another center back at roster freeze deadline?

Next to Michael Boxall is newly promoted starter Brent Kallman

MLS: Minnesota United FC at Real Salt Lake
Minnesota United defender Brent Kallman reacts to a miscommunication against Real Salt Lake in the second half at Rio Tinto Stadium on Aug. 31, 2022.
Jeffrey Swinger / USA Today Sports
We are part of The Trust Project.

When Minnesota United lost Bakaye Dibassy to a season-ending quad injury last Saturday, some Loons fans put John Brooks at the top of their wish list.

They tried to tweet it into existence; it was cute.

The U.S. men’s national team center back was a free agent after playing in the German Bundisliga, meaning Brooks was technically available for MNUFC to bring in before the MLS roster freeze deadline Friday.

But logistically, it wasn’t going to work for Minnesota.

Loons sporting director Mark Watson explained Friday the club’s lack of flexibility to add a center back within a tight time frame. He spoke generally, not about the Brooks pipe dream.


While Brooks didn’t need an international roster spot, Minnesota lacked not only that, but two other primary necessities to bring any central defender in — a roster spot and salary budget space.

“We were struggling on all three,” Watson said. “We basically made our plan and our decisions at the end of the (summer transfer) window with all of the above.”

After sending underwhelming forward Adrien Hunou back to France, Minnesota brought in forward Mender Garcia from Colombia. With Romain Metanire plagued by hamstring injuries, MNUFC acquired fullback Alan Benitez from Paraguay. And as Hassani Dotson and Jacori went down with season-ending leg injuries, United reinforced central midfield with Jonathan Gonzalez from Mexico.

It wasn’t like MNUFC didn’t consider adding another center back to the depth chart. “That is the first thing you think about; we just don’t have that ability,” Watson said.

Minnesota locked in the sixth seed and will travel to No. 3 FC Dallas for a first-round match next week.
The Loons’ kit men are responsible for setting up the team’s oval-shaped locker room at Allianz Field, with everything players need to perform — from emergency headgear down to their socked toes.
Fragapane is on a team-friendly guaranteed compensation of $257,000, per MLSPA, and has been one of the most productive Loons over his two seasons.
MNUFC went into Saturday’s match in California with an opportunity to clinch a playoff spot with a win and some help. That assistance came with Real Salt Lake’s draw with L.A. Galaxy late Saturday
With Minnesota’s playoff positioning slipping in three straight scoreless losses, a goal and a point will be precious. But they lost points from a winning position at home.
Third-place Minnesota (13-9-5) travels to sixth-place Real Salt Lake (10-8-9) for an 8:30 p.m. CT kickoff Wednesday at Rio Tinto Stadium in Sandy, Utah.
Seven field players have played at least 90% of the minutes across the five MLS matches since June 25. Two more, for a total of nine, have been on the field at least 78% of the game action in that
If the goalkeeper isn’t voted in, he can be added by United manager Adrian Heath
Minnesota United also working to send forward Adrien Hunou back to France
Minnesota United will play its ninth different starting lineup in the season’s ninth game on Sunday

Next to Michael Boxall, it’s newly promoted starter Brent Kallman, followed by Nabi Kibunguchy, Callum Montgomery and possibly other players coming in from other positions for emergencies.

Besides the actual constraints, Watson said other variables need to be considered. If the player comes from Europe, per se, they likely would need to get fit given the differing season schedules. If they need a work permit, there is added lag time. Both of those factors could delay a player’s time to influence, and the regular season has only five weeks remaining.

“It’s kind of a nonstarter,” Watson said. “And to support Adrian’s comment, we really like the group we’ve built, a lot of depth that has been tested this year.”

Kallman is expected to start next to Boxall as third-place Minnesota (13-10-5, 44 points) plays host to fourth-place FC Dallas (11-10-8, 43 points) at 2:30 p.m. Saturday at Allianz Field.


“Certain fixtures take on more significance at certain times of the year; that is what’s happening (Saturday),” Heath said.

The Loons defense, which struggled in a 3-0 loss to Real Salt Lake on Wednesday, will have its hands full with Dallas’ dangerous attackers, primarily Jesus Ferreria. The U.S. men’s national team striker has 15 goals in 28 games this season.

Reflecting on RSL, Heath searched for the right way to describe the trio of goals conceded. He settled on a kind description. “I thought the goals we conceded … — what’s the best way of describing it? — we enhanced the opportunities for them,” Heath said. “Let’s put it that way. I don’t think we defended well.”

Goalkeeper Dayne St. Clair had a negative X-ray on his dislocated finger suffered in the first half Wednesday. He was subbed out at halftime, when trailing 2-0, but will be available Saturday with a modified glove intended to ease impact on his hand.

Left back Kemar Lawrence, who has missed the past three games with a knee strain, was involved in the open portion of Friday’s training session. Heath said the Jamaican is available to play Saturday.


The Loons’ transfer fee to acquire Garcia from Colombian club Once Caldas was $1.4 million. … MNUFC obtained Benitez without a fee to Paraguayan club Cerro Porteno as the 28-year-old was coming to the end of his contract. Another MLS club had put in an estimated $1.5 million bid for Benitez roughly 18 months ago, the Pioneer Press learned this week. … MNUFC and The Toro Company have rebuilt a soccer field at Arlington Hills Community Center in St. Paul to help provide equitable access to the sport. The Loons and partners have done at least half dozen of these fields, futsal courts and gyms in the Twin Cities area over the past few years.


This story was written by one of our partner news agencies. Forum Communications Company uses content from agencies such as Reuters, Kaiser Health News, Tribune News Service and others to provide a wider range of news to our readers. Learn more about the news services FCC uses here.

What to read next
Adam and Caitlin Thielen started the Thielen Foundation in 2018 and have donated more than $2.5M to various organizations.
Fullback C.J. Ham and defensive tackle Jonathan Bullard also missed practice.
Jefferson already has 88 catches for 1,277 yards and is on pace to set new career highs in virtually every stat category.
Though it’s unclear how long Steel will stay at No. 1 center, he has done enough over the past few weeks to build trust.